Showing posts with label safety. Show all posts
Showing posts with label safety. Show all posts

Sunday, November 9, 2008

Are electric scooters safe?

So I was reading about an electric scooter company called Vectrix based out of Rhode Island. They produce an electric scooter that's comparable to a gasoline-powered one. It can reach up to 62 mph and can travel 65 miles between charges. The company only has one model out, the V1, and it's a bit pricy, over $5,000, but still cheaper than a car, both to buy and operate. It's also larger than most scooters and highway legal.But no one is buying them because they aren't available in many places. Apparently they were hoping Piaggio or another scooter company would buy the design from them, but it didn't flesh out. They are finally opening sales centers throughout the U.S.If I get a bigger scooter, I'd definitely prefer electric, but my  boyfriend brought up some good issues. I've heard of people with electric vehicles just plugging in to the first electric socket they could find, but don't people mind? Eventually as, or if, electric vehicles become more popular and prolific, those who have electric sockets out in the open and easily accessible might start getting big bills from their electric companies, unless the infrastructure is put in place at gas stations. I'd get a little annoyed as a home or business owner if someone just walked up to my house or business and plugged in their car or scooter.The other question my boyfriend raised is the safety of the vehicle in an accident.I looked it up and MSN autos had a good article talking about this subject. According to the editorial, it said emergency workers are currently taught to make sure the key is out of the ignition and the battery cables are cut on a gasoline powered vehicle before a rescue to make sure airbags don't suddenly deploy during a rescue, which could cause serious injury to EMTs and the injured. According to the editorial, hybrid cars and electric vehicles are designed so once there is no charge from the ignition, there is no charge running through the car. As for scooters, most of the time the injured party is far from the wreckage, so I don't see it as being a hazard to EMTs. Tow truck drivers and mechanics, on the other hand, would have to worry since they'd be dealing with the damaged system.But isn't there always a danger to them from a damaged vehicle? You might as well say gasoline powered cars are too dangerous because they can catch fire and they have toxic liquids leaking everywhere after a crash. So mechanics have a choice: get blown up or electrocuted. As mechanics, they should be well-versed on how all vehicles they might come in contact with should be handled and fixed, shouldn't they? A doctor wouldn't have any excuse for not knowing about a disease or how to treat it, aren't they supposed to keep up on the latest news and information to be an effective doctor?Personally, I think safety is a really weak argument against electric cars or scooters. No vehicle is going to be absolutely and undeniable safe. Even horses and carriages are full of danger, you can get run over by the horse or the carriage could go out of control and crash into a tree or over a cliff.I also found a blog post recently on "V is for Voltage Forums" about whether or not loud pipes save lives and if electric scooters and motorcycles had that against them in the safety arena. The poster, reikiman, made a good point, loud pipes don't always factor into whether a driver is paying attention before they slam into a motorcyclist. Regardless of whether your scooter or motorcycle is quiet or loud, safety really is depenedent on the cyclist because drivers just don't pay attention.

Sunday, August 17, 2008

A scary series of warnings

This week in my town three people have suffered serious injuries, all of which could have been lessened by the use of a helmet. A man crashed after trying to pass someone on the highway and he is still in the hospital with serious injuries. No helmet.
A little girl rode right through a stop sign without looking and ran into a car. She's also still in the hospital. Again, no helmet. And an ATV passenger was seriously injured when the vehicle she was on the back of had a serious accident. The driver, who turned out to be drunk, had a helmet on, but the girl didn't. She's also in the hospital looking forward to surgeries and a long stay.
It's one of those things so often overlooked. The uncomfortable, dorky looking helmet. But when you are flying at an object, out of control, you're really going to be wishing you had one.
I've heard many people argue that if you drive safely you don't have to wear a helmet. But what about the millions of other motorists on the road? Do you think they are driving safely. It's such a roullette game to think that way. There's only one guarantee, if you get into an accident without a helmet, you could be a vegetable.
The National Highway Traffic and Safety Administration recently released a report on motorcycles and crashes. Out of more than 4,000 accidents it found the following to be true:

* The majority of motorcycle crashes involved another vehicle, usually an automobile.

* A motorcyclist is 37 percent more likely to die in a crash, per mile traveled. Mostly because there is no roll cage protecting their body.

* In those fatal crashes, head injury was the leading cause of death.

* Helmets reduce the liklihood of fatality by 37 percent. So if you're 37 percent more likely to get into a crash wouldn't you like that same percentage to favor your chance of living, and not like a vegetable?

* In its evaluation of crashe, the NHTSA found that helmets are 67 percent effective in preventing brain injuries. While I would love it to be 100 percent, it's still way better than the 0 percent effectiveness of not wearing a helmet.

* From 1984 to 2006, helmets saved the lives of more than 19,000 motorcyclists. The NHTSA says if all the people involved in fatal crashes in that time period had worn helmets, more than 12,000 people would have been saved.

* The NHTSA also found that in states where only minors were required to wear helmets when riding on two wheels, only 40 percent of children wore them. So leading by example does happen. Betcha if mom and dad wore helmets the kids wouldn't be so hesitant to put them on.

Now, I'm not sure if I like the idea of people being forced to do something. I've always been of the philosophy if someone does something dumb and gets hurt, why should the rest of us be legislated to death because of it? However, when it costs me money because someone is doing something dumb, I've got an issue with it.


According to the NHTSA report, costs to cover medical bills for motorcyclists in Florida who didn't wear a helmet and crashed were $10.5 million for "charitable and public sources." That is 21 percent of the motorcycling population involved in an accident in Florida .. just Florida. The report said one of those public sources was Medicaid.

Last time I checked my pay stub, I had an awful lot going to that program. While I don't mind helping someone out who is in need, I do mind that money being used to help someone who made a stupid decision when they should have known better. I'd rather see it go to help someone who's suffering isn't their own fault.

Now, before anyone starts lambasting me for being "anti-motorcyle," I'm not. I love motorcycles. I think motorcyclists too often get a bad rap. I'm just concerned that with the increase in popularity of motorcycles (and scooters which are often grouped in that "class" of vehicle) stupidity will take over and smart riders will suffer because of it, if not all ready. There's enough of a stigmatism attached to riding on two wheels, shouldn't the motorcycling and scootering communities be pushing for responsibility before we start getting legislated to death? It hasn't happened yet, but it certainly could.

Sunday, July 20, 2008

A little thing called safety

For some reason people think scooters are safer than motorcycles.
Sure, they run a little differently. Most scooters don't have a clutch you worry about and brake handles on both handlebars, but many of them can go just as fast as a car. So why is it people think they are safer and don't require a layer of protection?
I wondered this when I visited Key West for what will probably be the only time.
In that island borough scooters are everywhere, and they aren't to strict about who can rent them. Problem is everyone goes around on them without a helmet or proper shoes.
Maybe it's the laid back element but just because it's a small machine with just enough power to go on a highway doesn't mean it can't lead to a dangerous situation.
Without the proper shoes you can have rocks fly up and cut your feet, or get them run over by an unthinking driver.
Just like a motorcycle, you're exposed to the elements, wind, rain, heat. So you should wear the proper clothing.
And just like a motorcycle, scooters are small, so unwitting drivers are less likely to notice you and more likely to pull out in front of you and cause a deadly accident.
Yet, too many people don't wear helmets when riding them. Don't wear the proper shoes. Don't wear pants that cover their legs and protect their skin from abrasions if they fall. Don't think that yes, it's small and fun to buzz around on, but that SUV following you isn't. And isn't thinking to be very careful.
That's up to the scooter driver.

And there are a lot of people who think anyone can do it. Watch the fool below who doesn't even buckle her helmet before she crashes. (Won't do you any good if it's not on your head!)